Elma Real Estate | Elma Homes for Sale

Great location for these 2 commercial properties being sold together, 5750 Seneca is a double and 5760 is a single family home, together there is 200 ft frontage by a generous 478 depth and both properties zoned commercial C2 , location is right next door to Elma water authority and just 3 doors down from busy Transit rd, both homes in good condition and fully occupied by month to month tenants, keep these homes for an investment or build your business here ! the property taxes listed include both properties and are full taxes with no exemptions. square footage / acreage and taxes are both buildings combined

5750 & 5760 Seneca Street, Elma

$249,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1698138 MLS

Welcome to this spacious 2,436-square-foot home, beautifully situated on more than three acres on a quiet dead-end street. Note the 338 feet of frontage. Offering three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, the home features generously sized rooms, incredible storage throughout, and large windows that fill the interior with abundant natural light. There is also a large den that could easily serve as a guest room with minor modification. Convenient first floor laundry. Outside, the expansive property will provide plenty of room to relax, garden, entertain, or simply enjoy the peaceful surroundings however you decide to modify it. The lovely gazebo creates a charming place to gather. Notable improvements include a new roof, gutters, and Gutter Helmet system installed in 2019, along with a whole-house gas-fired generator and updated electrical panel installed in 2013. The forced-air furnace and central air-conditioning system also appear to be relatively recent installations. Roof, gutters, gutter helmet and generator are recent installations. Receipts for this work are in attachments as well as notes found in the house regardng the septic. A fireplace, previously used for wood burning, adds character; however, no representation is made regarding code compliance or future use. Enjoy a private setting without sacrificing convenience—stores, shopping, schools, and recreational activities are all just a short distance away. This special property offers space, comfort, natural light, and an exceptional opportunity to make it your own. The price reflects the need for interior and exterior modifications to suit your taste. Deadline for offers is July 29, 2026 at 11am.

51 S Ostrander Road, Elma

$899,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1696051 MLS

Welcome to this Exceptional R. Borst custom built 3200+ sq ft home set on 5+ acres, The spectacular lot has open greenspace, wooded areas and a pretty little brook running thru the property on the north side. This meticulously maintained home features 3 bedrooms and 3 baths. The impressive 1st floor boasts 9' ceilings, large entry foyer and exquisite custom woodwork. The custom built-ins in the Den and around the fireplace are stunning. Extremely spacious kitchen has loads of tall natural maple cabinets, hardwood floors, a generous work space, an Island with a prep sink, top of the line appliances and a full walk-in Butler's pantry, make this kitchen a cooks dream. Separate eating area and another open area that could be the perfect computer/work space. Large formal dining room designed for entertaining. The den is impressive with an entire wall of built-ins. This room also has 2 closets, could be the perfect guest room. The Primary Suite has 2 walk-in closets and a massive ensuite bath with whirlpool tub, L-shaped vanity with 2 sinks, large shower and separate water closet. 2 sets of doors from the living room or the kitchen lead to the over sized Trex deck with brand new canvas awning. This deck overlooks the backyard with lovely gardens and the brook. Large 1st floor laundry with closet and more storage. Large enough for a sewing or craft room. 2nd floor has 2 good sized bedrooms and a full bath and another unfinished room for added storage. Basement is unfinished with 3 egress points. This space can't wait to be finished. The garage has an epoxy floor and the 3rd bay is heated and ready to be used as a work shop. The house has an updated furnace and tankless hot water tank, full house generator, shed and solar panels. Combining exceptional craftmanship, modern conveniences and the privacy of this 5+ acre setting, this remarkable property offers the perfect balance of elegance, functionality and country living - all while remaining conveniently located to the village of EA, Rt 400 access, restaurants and shopping. Showings begin immediately. Open House Thursday July 23rd 5-7pm. Owners reserve the right to set an offer deadline.

30 Meadowbrook Drive, Elma

$399,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1699188 MLS

Welcome home to this charming 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath, 1,994 sqft Colonial w/ a 2.5 car garage nestled on a spacious 135' x 250' lot in the highly desirable Iroquois Central School District! This single-owner home has been well-maintained featuring a grand front foyer, hardwood floors under the carpet in all 4 bdrms & a functional layout designed for comfortable everyday living along w/ a bonus cedar closet for pristine clothing storage! The kitchen features ample cabinetry & generous countertop space, providing plenty of room for meal preparation & storage. Kitchen appliances inlcd: Refrigerator, built-in gas oven, Gas cook-top & dishwasher. Formal dining/living room provides versatility. The open full basement offers plenty of storage & entertaining space. Enjoy the covered patio overlooking the tranquil park-like backyard w/ endless possibilities for outdoor fun. This home is beautifully accented by a vibrant crimson tree that perfectly matches its storybook street name. Recent Updates: HWT ('25), electrical service line ('26), updated electric panel & a partially rebuilt chimney w/ tuck-pointing ('26) offer added value & peace of mind. Conveniently located w/ easy access to local amenities & the 400 (Aurora Expressway),Transit Road or Bullis Road, offering quick commuting access to downtown Buffalo. This Elma home is ready for its next chapter!

10 Crimson Lane, Elma

$275,000

B1699120 MLS

Build Your Dream Home on a Rare 5.09-Acre Wooded Lot in Elma! An exceptional opportunity to own a beautiful 5.09-acre level wooded lot located at 1840 W. Blood Rd., Elma, NY. Nestled on one of Elma's most desirable streets, this property offers the perfect blend of privacy, natural beauty, and convenience. Vacant lots on W. Blood Road rarely become available, making this a unique chance to create the custom home you've always envisioned. The level terrain provides an ideal building site while the mature trees offer a peaceful setting and the flexibility to design your own private retreat. Whether you're looking to build your forever home or invest in a highly sought-after location, this property offers endless possibilities. Enjoy the tranquility of country living while remaining just minutes from shopping, dining, schools, and major commuter routes. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a prime piece of Elma real estate and bring your dream home to life!

1840 W Blood Road, Elma

$529,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1694926 MLS

LOCATION- LOCATION-LOCATION - DEAD END/CUL-DE-SAC - BEAUTIFUL HIDDEN TREED NEIGHBORHOOD OFFERS THIS MOVE-IN CONDITION 4 BR, 2.5 bath home! Air conditioning, new boiler, heated kitchen tile floors, vaulted ceiling w/ full masonary fireplace currently w/ gas insert but could go back to woodburning if desired! Access to spacious wood deck and hot tub. Awesome bonus room in basement w/ nice size workshop, separate laundry and full bath - loads for storage! GARAGE IS HEATED W/ PULL-DOWN ACCESS FOR MORE STORAGE! Private treed back yard with 2 sheds - one has elec and water! IRRIGATION SYSTEM IN BACK YARD!! TOWN OF ELMA, IROQUOIS SCHOOLS, LANCASTER MAILING!

41 Tiffany Lane, Elma

$1,599,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1668196 MLS

Welcome to 1220 Rice Rd - an exceptional custom-built mid-century modern ranch perfectly situated on 2.1 private acres in the highly desirable Iroquois School District. Designed and built by award winning architects, Crafted Concepts, this stunning and sustainable home offers an unmatched blend of design, thoughtful layout, and cutting edge building science to provide an exceptional living experience. This model, the Varnsen, represents a take on mid century design with arched details, patterns, soaring ceilings, and open spaces. Step inside the front double doors, and be welcomed into the bright foyer, bathed in natural light from the large picture window that frames your central patio. To the right, you will find the expansive kitchen, living, and dining area. With fully custom cabinets, a walk-in pantry, ceilings up to 18', and large custom windows, this space is an entertainer's dream. This breathtaking space is anchored by an arched dual sided gas fireplace that separates the living room. Retreat to your large primary suite, complete with a stunning bath with soaking tub, curbless shower, and playful arches. This space also has dual closets for ample storage with custom California Closet systems. The main floor also contains two additional generously sized bedrooms, the second full bath, and laundry room.On the lower level, you will find an additional 1,030sqft of finished living space with a large walk out slider with additional concrete patio. Notable upgrades include a full ICF foundation, LP SmartSide Siding, Marvin windows, dual HVAC systems, smart home system, and custom millwork in the kitchen, and fireplace divider. Completed in July 2026, this is a rare opportunity to own a beautifully crafted, future-forward home that combines cutting edge performance with timeless design. Lot has been seeded for grass, photos are rendered.

1220 Rice Road, Elma

$349,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1697103 MLS

Welcome to this spacious 3/4-bedroom split-level home situated on a beautiful, over 3/4-acre wooded lot in one of Elma's desirable low-traffic neighborhoods. The inviting living room features a central gas fireplace, creating a warm and welcoming gathering space. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of room for cooking and entertaining and includes a breakfast/sitting area with sliding glass doors leading directly to the rear patio, making indoor and outdoor living a breeze. Upstairs you'll find four generously sized rooms, offering the flexibility of a traditional four-bedroom layout or three bedrooms plus a dedicated home office. A centrally located full bath serves the secondary bedrooms, while the primary bedroom enjoys the convenience of its own private full bath. The lower level expands your living space with a large, finished recreation room complete with a bar area and an additional room that's perfect for hosting football and hockey parties, a game room, or hobby space. A separate basement workshop/storage area provides plenty of room for projects or extra storage, while a conveniently located half bath and laundry area complete the lower level. An attached 2 car garage and shed rounds out your storage. Outside, enjoy the privacy of the large, wooded backyard in a peaceful neighborhood setting. An excellent floor plan, and endless potential, this home is ready for your personal finishing touches to make it your own. Don't miss this outstanding opportunity in the heart of Elma!

303 Hilltop Drive, Elma

$335,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1697003 MLS

Set on a full 1.45 acres in Elma, this 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home gives you space that's hard to find this close to everything. The first floor bathroom has a brand new tiled walk in shower with sliding glass door, full bathroom vanity, linen closet cabinet storage. Covered front porch welcomes you in, and the layout keeps things simple and functional with an attached garage and a full basement that's ready for whatever you need it to be, storage, a workshop, a future rec room, you name it. Furnace and central air keep you comfortable year round. Aluminum/vinyl exterior means low maintenance on the outside so you can spend your time enjoying the acre plus of land instead of working on it. There's also a shed out back for extra storage or a place to keep the yard equipment. Located in the Iroquois Central School District, this is the kind of lot you don't see often, room to breathe, room to grow into, all within easy reach of everyday conveniences. Won't last at this size and location, must see.

5941 Seneca Street, Elma

$599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1696559 MLS

Welcome to 1581 Jamison Road, where classic farmhouse charm meets modern updates on a beautiful piece of Elma. Thoughtfully modernized, this home showcases the character of a traditional farmhouse with an updated kitchen and recently renovated bathrooms, creating a comfortable space that's ready to enjoy. The kitchen has its own gas fireplace while the living room has a wood burning fireplace as well. The open staircase is the perfect centerpiece to the home and once you are upstairs the primary bathroom has an expansive space with a sunken shower. Step outside to find well-maintained landscaping, a spacious yard, and a hot tub that stays with the home—perfect for relaxing after a long day. The iconic full red barn offers endless possibilities, whether you need storage, a workshop, space for hobbies, animals, or future projects. The surrounding land provides room to spread out and enjoy the outdoors. This is a great example of everything Elma has to offer: open space, country character, and a home that blends timeless appeal with today's updates. Showings will begin immediately Open House Saturday 7/25/26 10am - Noon

1581 Jamison Road, Elma

$319,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1678407 MLS

This beautifully maintained Townhouse will allow you effortless living. 2 bedroom, 2.5 bath. Spacious living room & dining room. The wood burning fireplace is the focal point of the open kitchen-family room combination and overlooks your private slate patio with awning. Vaulted ceilings. First floor laundry. The loft is ideal for hobbies, crafts or office. The primary bedroom offers large walk-in closet & spacious bath with double vanities. New roof is paid in full and was completed June 2026. Pond Brook is a very appealing community development and its location is second to none. Elma Plaza offers pharmacy, gift shop, pizzeria, liquor store and hardware store. Minutes to the 400 and Village of East Aurora.

18 Old Mill Circle, Elma

$389,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1692208 MLS

Zillow taxes are wrong they are $242 a month, not $595 a month. It would be hard to be much closer to The Village of East Aurora, without actually being in The Village of East Aurora. Located instead in the very highly regarded Iroquois Schools and extremely low taxes. Check out this updated and spacious 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath Traditional style home set on large(.73 acre) lot. Low maintenance exterior with vinyl siding, new landscaping throughout the grounds. Stunning new hardwood floors throughout the second floor, freshly painted throughout, completed gutted and updated full bath, including a never before walk-in shower and soaking tub and all new plumbing, new vanity. 1st floor laundry, updated half bath, brand new carpeting on stairs, new flooring in LR, new light fixtures throughout most of the house. Over 1700 sq. ft plus an oversized deck with composite material. large 2.5 car garage. Above ground pool sold "as is". Large eat in kitchen with stainless steel refrigerator and gas oven. Easy to show. Some photos have been virtually enhanced. Square footage has been verified & documented by a licensed appraiser. See attachments. Open house Wed. 7/8 from 5-7pm and Sunday 7/12 from 1-3pm

7881 Seneca Street, Elma

$539,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1693791 MLS

Rare opportunity to own a beautiful patio home on a corner lot in the highly sought after Springbrook Shores community. This former model home offers two spacious bedrooms and a loft which can easily double as an office or a third bedroom with a walk-in closet. Two full baths, laundry room, eat-in kitchen, and combined dining/living room with a vaulted ceiling complement this first floor open plan. Enjoy cozying up to the gas fireplace, while enjoying your favorite movie/music with a built-in surround sound system. Seamless luxury vinyl flooring and warm neutral colors, create a soft glow throughout this home that is unparalleled in beauty. New central air, hot water tank, and a brand new Generac whole home generator will never leave you in the dark. Front patio and rear vinyl deck allow you to enjoy the wildlife from the comfort of your home. The beautifully landscaped property is further secluded with mature pine trees on the east side of the property. Condo status provides a tax break for its residents while the homeowners association handles all landscaping and snow removal. This community boasts a private nature trail for residents to enjoy long walks while taking in all the wildlife this community offers. Attached two-car garage floor is coated for an added layer of protection, while the full basement boasts an 8-foot ceiling for plenty of storage. In ground sprinkler system and electronic home security complete this home designed for carefree living. This home won’t be on the market for long!

2 S Shore Drive, Elma

$475,000

B1692443 MLS

Historic commercial building in the Town of Elma offering character, flexibility, and a wide range of potential uses. Once a tavern and the local post office, this well-maintained property has also served as a bar/restaurant, office building, and field office. Located on Jamison Road, a county-maintained road with easy access to NY Route 400, the building is zoned C-2, allowing for possible uses such as office, retail, restaurant, child care, and art studio space. Interior highlights include hardwood and tile floors, 12-foot ceilings, and a hand-carved wooden bar, while modern updates include a 2-zone security system, VPN lines, and a backup generator. A unique opportunity to bring your business to a property that combines historic charm with present-day functionality.

1091 Jamison Road, Elma

$500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1692659 MLS

Seller will accept offers between $500,000 and $550,000. There's never been a better time to upgrade! Get into this spacious & updated home before summer is out and start fresh in highly rated Iroquois School District. This home has been thoughtfully renovated throughout with neutral paint colors, waterproof LVP flooring, all new windows, 5 year old tear off roof and all new siding. Inside you'll find a spacious master bedroom, 3 additional bedrooms and a dedicated office that could serve as a 5th bedroom or anything extra you need. There are 2 full bathrooms, a dedicated laundry room with gleaming granite and a full living room upstairs as well as downstairs. This makes the home easily able to provide an in-law setup. The kitchen is a full remodel with maple cabinets, tier IV quartzite stone countertops and counter to ceiling backsplash. The open feeling throughout is great for entertaining as well as heat and cool airflow. Walk out the new sliding glass doors to a huge 2-level deck that leads down to the pool. Here you have a gorgeous view of the entire property and can hear the creek. The entire property's landscape has been designed with gorgeous and low maintenance perennials and you'll love being set back and away from the road. The privacy and security is a rare fine. The shed is currently a chicken coop but could be converted back at zero cost. Expansive driveway is able to park several cars, recreational vehicles or whatever you may have. This house is built for families who love to the outdoors and entertaining. All improvements were done with children, pets and durability in mind. Some notes: downstairs chimney has been recently inspected and is ready for wood stove installation. 200amp service has a generator plug. Property is not in a flood zone. 2 large AC units are included in the sale. Appliances stay (except washer and dryer). Second property parcel is included in this sale.

170 Creek Road, Elma

Elma Homes for Sale

Newest Elma Homes for Sale